Mount Kilimanjaro, Africa’s highest peak, stands at 19,341 feet (5,895 meters) above sea level. It attracts thousands of adventurers each year. Among its several routes to the summit, the Western Breach is both the most challenging and controversial. Known for its steep ascent and unstable terrain, the Western Breach has earned a reputation for being perilous. Despite the allure of a less-traveled path with stunning views, the risks associated with this route, including a history of fatalities, make it a route we do not guide.
The Allure of the Western Breach
The Western Breach route from the Shira Plateau offers climbers a more direct but significantly steeper path to the summit. This route’s appeal lies in its dramatic landscapes, including the stunning Lava Tower, Arrow Glacier, and the final ascent through the Western Breach itself—a gap in the crater rim caused by a historical volcanic eruption. The technical challenges and the route’s relative solitude compared to the more popular Marangu and Machame routes are particularly enticing for seasoned climbers.
Fatalities on the Western Breach
However, the beauty and solitude of the Western Breach come with substantial risks. The route has been the site of several fatalities over the years, primarily due to rock falls and the harsh alpine environment. One of the most tragic incidents occurred in January 2006, when a massive rock fall resulted in the deaths of three American climbers and seriously injured others. This incident led to the temporary closure of the route by Tanzanian authorities.
The high-risk factors are not limited to rock falls. Climbers also face the challenges of high altitude, severe weather conditions, and the physical demands of the steep and rocky terrain. Unlike other routes, the Western Breach offers little in the way of gradual acclimatization, increasing the risk of altitude sickness. The Arrow Glacier Camp, positioned at around 15,748 feet (4,800 meters), provides minimal protection against the elements, making it a treacherous spot to spend the night before the final push to the summit.
Reasons to Avoid the Western Breach
Safety Concerns: The primary reason to avoid the Western Breach is the significant safety hazards. The risk of rock falls is a constant threat, and the route’s steepness can lead to dangerous slips and falls. The 2006 incident underscored the potential for tragedy, prompting many guides and operators to steer climbers toward safer alternatives.
Technical Difficulty: The Western Breach is the most technically demanding route on Kilimanjaro. It requires climbers to have prior experience with high-altitude trekking and rock scrambling. Those without sufficient experience and fitness levels are more susceptible to accidents and severe altitude sickness. The trail is eroded from rock falls and crosses several scree slopes en route to the Breach itself.
Limited Acclimatization: Unlike the more gradual ascent profiles of the Northern Circuit or Lemosho routes, the Western Breach offers limited opportunities for acclimatization. Rapid altitude gain increases the risk of acute mountain sickness (AMS), which can be fatal if not managed properly.
Unpredictable Weather: The high-altitude weather on Kilimanjaro can be unpredictable and harsh. Climbers on the Western Breach are exposed to the elements with fewer options for shelter compared to other routes. Sudden weather changes can turn a challenging climb into a dangerous ordeal.
Rock falls are frequent on the Western Breach. Here is a video of one near the summit, viewed from Karanga Camp.
Final Thoughts
While the Western Breach route on Mount Kilimanjaro offers a unique and scenic path to the summit, the inherent risks and technical challenges make it a less advisable option for most climbers. The history of fatalities, combined with the demanding nature of the route, serves as a stark reminder of the potential dangers. For those considering an ascent of Kilimanjaro, opting for a safer and more manageable route not only increases the chances of a successful summit but also ensures a safer and more enjoyable climbing experience.